Caralan Trust, et al. - Page 24




                                       - 24 -                                         
          142(a); sec. I. supra.  They must prove facts establishing that             
          Alexion Trust is neither a sham, a grantor trust, nor that the              
          income of Alexion Trust is taxable to Joseph and Frances Shirley            
          under assignment of income principles.  They must prove facts               
          establishing that they are entitled to the depreciation deduction           
          claimed with respect to property of Caralan Trust.  They have               
          done neither.                                                               
                    3.  Discussion                                                    
                    a.  Alexion Trust Gross Receipts                                  
                    (1)  Introduction                                                 
               Alexion Trust was created by the J. Shirleys on September 1,           
          1994.  The J. Shirleys exercised control over the Alexion Trust,            
          as evidenced by their signatory authority over the trust’s bank             
          accounts (out of which they paid their personal expenses) and               
          Joseph Shirley’s signature on the Alexion Trust 1995 return as              
          fiduciary.  Alexion Trust reported gross receipts for 1995 of               
          $179,791 from an activity described as computer consulting.  One            
          or both of the J. Shirleys performed all or substantially all of            
          the consulting services generating such receipts.  They reported            
          no income on account of performing such services, and Alexion               
          Trust claimed no deduction for wages paid.  Prior to 1995, one or           
          both of the J. Shirleys engaged in the computer consulting                  
          business, paying self-employment tax on the net profits of the              
          business.  Those facts are sufficient for us to find that the J.            






Page:  Previous  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  29  30  31  32  33  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011