David D. Brayshaw and Nora D. Brayshaw - Page 18




                                               - 17 -                                                  
            deduction may be allowed to the extent that the item is allocable                          
            to a portion of the home which is exclusively used on a regular                            
            basis as the principal place of business for the taxpayer’s trade                          
            or business. Sec. 280A(c)(1)(A).                                                           
                  Petitioners argue that 43 percent of their residence was                             
            used exclusively for business purposes; we find that 12.7 percent                          
            of the residence was so used.  We reject petitioners’ argument                             
            that portions of the middle and bottom floors and the garage were                          
            used exclusively for business:  Certain areas purportedly were                             
            set up for use by Ms. Brayshaw, who was not engaged in her                                 
            medical business in the year in issue.  Other areas contained                              
            inherently personal items, such as a fireplace and sofas, or were                          
            for storage which was not necessarily related to Mr. Brayshaw’s                            
            businesses.  Finally, we have found that the Jeep was not used                             
            exclusively for business purposes; consequently, the garage in                             
            which it was stored likewise was not so used.  On the other hand,                          
            we accept Mr. Brayshaw’s testimony–corroborated by photographs--                           
            that portions of the top floor were used exclusively as his                                
            principal place of business with respect to his several                                    
            businesses.  We therefore find that 228.75 square feet, of the                             
            total 1,804.32 square feet, were used exclusively and regularly                            
            as Mr. Brayshaw’s principal place of business.  Petitioners are                            
            entitled to deductions for the applicable percentage of the                                
            following substantiated expenses which were paid by petitioners:                           






Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011