James J. Coyle - Page 15




                                       - 14 -                                         
          these adjustments until our discussion of the fraud penalty and             
          the period of limitations.                                                  
          2.  Mr. Coyle                                                               
               Respondent determined that Mr. Coyle failed to report                  
          commission income received from Regal of $21,130 in 1992 and                
          $18,816 in 1993.  The commission income consisted of the income             
          which Regal received from sales of wheels and axles and which Mr.           
          Coyle diverted from Regal.  Mr. Coyle reported $23,920 in 1992              
          and $26,340 in 1993 of “other” income (not “commission” income)             
          on his Federal income tax returns.3                                         
               In our discussion above, we have concluded that Regal                  
          received gross receipts from sales of wheels and axles and that             
          the funds received were paid to Mr. Coyle.  The discussion here             
          provides further support for our conclusion that Mr. Coyle failed           
          to report commission income as determined in the notice of                  
          deficiency.                                                                 
               Respondent elicited testimony from four of Regal’s former              
          employees concerning their involvement with sales of wheels and             
          axles.  All four provided credible testimony that Mr. Coyle was             
          the person who received the cash from sales of wheels and axles             
          or, if he was not available at that time, the cash would                    
          ultimately be turned over to him.  Mr. Coyle has admitted that              


               3  Regal paid its other salespeople a commission for each              
          mobile home sold.                                                           





Page:  Previous  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  Next

Last modified: May 25, 2011