Ex parte HOLT et al. - Page 9




              Appeal No. 95-3175                                                                                                                          
              Application 08/124,361                                                                                                                      

              information for inclusion on printed reports" (column 1, lines 60-62), which allows "characterization of said                               

              vehicle operating expenses and said travel expenses for tax purposes," as recited in claim 15.  For example,                                

              in figure 4B "the user is prompted at step 69 to enter the reason for the mileage traveled" (column 5,                                      

              lines 6-7).                                                                                                                                 

                       Fogg discloses a trip distance recorder for a motor vehicle connected to a mileage sensor to                                       

              measure the distance traveled (e.g., column 3, approx. lines 30-42; column 4, lines 24-30).  The sensor                                     

              may be a drive shaft sensor (column 3, lines 30-42).  Fogg discloses that the trips may be characterized                                    

              by one of ten trip types (column 3, lines 64-66; column 4, table I).  The system in figure 2 of Fogg is "a data                             

              storage and internal processor responsive to said mileage sensor and manual input, having a                                                 

              microcomputer, a real time clock, and random access memory," as recited in claim 15.  The real time clock                                   

              is not shown but is described, for example, in column 4.  Fogg further discloses a calibration procedure to                                 

              calibrate the TICKS/TENTH parameter value (e.g., column 6, lines 30-68; column 5, line 52, to                                               

              column 10, line 20).                                                                                                                        

                       Whitaker shows a device for recording distances for personal and business use using a vehicle                                      

              speed sensor.  A mileage sensor attached to the vehicle is connected to the device for recording miles                                      

              driven (column 3, lines 43-46).  "The speed pick-up can be from the drive shaft, transmission, speedometer                                  

              cable or electronic control module (ECM)/electronic control unit (ECU)" (column 3, lines 10-12).  The                                       

              purpose of the trip can be characterized as "business," "investment," or "personal" (default) (column 3,                                    

              line 62, to column 4, line 10).  The system in figures 3-6 of Whitaker is "a data storage and internal                                      

                                                                      - 9 -                                                                               





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007