Ex parte HOLT et al. - Page 10




              Appeal No. 95-3175                                                                                                                          
              Application 08/124,361                                                                                                                      

              processor responsive to said mileage sensor and manual input, having a microcomputer, a real time clock,                                    

              and random access memory," as recited in claim 15.  Whitaker discloses (column 7, lines 64, to column                                       

              8, line 8):                                                                                                                                 

                       The calculated odometer reading may, however, vary somewhat from the reading of the mechanical                                     
                       odometer within the vehicle.  Therefore, to prevent loss of confidence by the operator in the data                                 
                       stored by the apparatus, microprocessor 60 is programmed to compare the next odometer reading                                      
                       entered through keypad 12 with that stored in data file 112, and to calculate therefrom a correction                               
                       factor that is applied to all calculated updates of vehicle mileage until the next odometer reading is                             
                       manually entered.  In this manner, the calculated values will more closely correspond with values                                  
                       indicated by the mechanical odometer.                                                                                              

              Therefore, Whitaker teaches a calibration system.                                                                                           

                       Gulas shows a device for recording distances traveled on personal and business use including a                                     

              vehicle speed sensor.  A mileage sensor attached to the vehicle is connected to the device for recording                                    

              miles driven (column 3, lines 27-45).  The device in Gulas "can include input keys for inputting details of                                 

              gas purchase and amount to keep an accurate record of the total costs for later division into the separate                                  

              characteristics" (column 2, lines 32-35); see also column 4, lines 35-41.  Thus, Gulas provides for                                         

              recording "vehicle travel mileage and vehicle operating expenses."  The mileage and expenses can be                                         

              characterized as business or non-business for tax purposes (e.g., column 3, lines 9-11; column 4, lines                                     

              26-34).                                                                                                                                     

                                                     Differences between the prior art                                                                    
                                                         and the claimed invention                                                                        




                                                                      - 10 -                                                                              





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007