Ex parte JOHN D. JENSEN - Page 7




                Appeal No. 95-4113                                                                                                            
                Application No. 08/124,334                                                                                                    


                axis also being at an acute angle with the axis of drum rotation.                                                             
                Independent claim 21 includes the limitations that the set of                                                                 
                circumferentially spaced nozzles each include a tip having an                                                                 
                axis generally disposed in a radial plane of the drum, the plane                                                              
                including the axis of drum rotation; the tips each being disposed                                                             
                within an imaginary cylindrical extension of the drum surface                                                                 
                extending outwardly from the side edge of the drum in a direction                                                             
                away from the remote side; and the tips each being oriented to                                                                
                direct a flame toward  a side of the drum and the cylindrical2                                                                                          
                extension at a location near the edge whereby to impinge on                                                                   
                superposed, juxtaposed edge portions of the web projecting from                                                               
                the surface past the side edge.                                                                                               


                         With respect to the above-identified limitations from                                                                
                independent claims 1, 21, 22 and 23, the examiner determined that                                                             
                         [i]t would have been obvious to one having ordinary                                                                  
                         skill in the art to have positioned the flame nozzle                                                                 
                         taught by McDowall at an acute angle, since Pommer                                                                   
                         recognizes the desirability of impinging a flame                                                                     

                         2We interpret the phrase "the tips each being oriented to                                                            
                direct a flame toward a side of the drum and the cylindrical                                                                  
                extension at a location near said edge" as requiring the tips to                                                              
                be an acute angle with respect to the axis of drum rotation so                                                                
                that the tips will direct the flames upwardly against the drum                                                                
                and the lower surface of the web.                                                                                             


                                                                      7                                                                       





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007