Ex parte ROBERT S. DREYER et al. - Page 6


            Appeal No. 96-1620                                                        
            Application No. 07/938,288                                                


                 As explained supra, with regard to claim 9, the CPUID                
            of Kurihara is used to distinguish between other processors               
            on a network and does not identify a particular type of                   
            processor.  Moreover, although claims 15 and 22 are method                
            claims, claim 15 still requires “…the contents of a                       
            microprocessor ID memory element within said microprocessor               
            that includes microprocessor ID data indicative of                        
            microprocessor type…” and claim 22 requires “a                            
            microprocessor ID memory element storing microprocessor ID                
            data including data fields that identify the microprocessor               
            type,” wherein such “microprocessor ID data” is an important              
            part of the claimed method.                                               
                 As explained supra, neither Durst nor Kurihara                       
            discloses or suggests such “microprocessor ID data” which                 
            uniquely identifies the microprocessor in use in the                      
            particular computer system of interest.  It follows,                      
            therefore, that neither reference nor a combination of them               
            can disclose or suggest the claimed method for identifying a              
            microprocessor that is a member of a set of compatible                    
            microprocessor families.                                                  







                                          6                                           



Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007