Ex parte VANRAES - Page 5




          Appeal No. 96-3480                                         Page 5           
          Application No. 08/142,381                                                  


               Claim 1 recites an auriaular hygiene device comprising,                
          inter alia, a cylindrical body having a longitudinal axis and               
          two opposed extremities and an active portion on one of the                 
          extremities.  The active portion includes, inter alia, a                    
          substantially circular active edge and a depression or cavity,              
          having a hemispherical outer surface shape with a                           
          predetermined radius.                                                       


               Tolman discloses an implement having a shank 2 and an ear              
          wax spoon 3 shaped as shown in Figures 1 and 2.                             


               Hartman discloses a conventional otoscope speculum having              
          a base 11, a conical portion 10 and a projection 12.  Hartman               
          teaches at the paragraph beginning at column 1, line 63, that               
                    [p]rojection 12 may assume a wide variety of shapes.              
               In general, any shape which is adapted to engage and                   
               remove wax in the ear canal may be used.  Such shapes                  
               include spoons, loops, and the like.  A particularly                   
               suitable shape, because of its efficiency for the                      
               purpose, comprises a substantially cylindrical extension               
               13 from a portion of the distal end of the speculum 10                 
               having a hood-like tip 14 on the end thereof.  Tip 14,                 
               may have a substantially hemispherical shape.                          










Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007