HOSHINO et al V. TANAKA - Page 20




          Interference No. 103,208                                                    
          Hoshino et al. v. Tanaka                                                    

          "[a] reply shall be directed only to new points raised in the               
          opposition."  To the extent that Hoshino believes that Motion               
          H2 itself makes out a prima facie basis for relief, we                      
          disagree.                                                                   
               In order to add a count to the interference, party                     
          Hoshino must demonstrate that the newly proposed count defines              
          a separately patentable invention relative to original count                
          1.   According to count 1, the "corrected conversion                        
          coefficient" representing a relationship between the lens                   
          driving amount and the detected amount of defocus is                        
          determined on the basis of three factors:                                   
                    (1) the conversion coefficient, (2) the                           
               correction coefficient, and (3) the detected amount                    
               of defocus.                                                            
               Hoshino’s proposed count 2 differs from count 1 by                     
          specifically and particularly reciting that the corrected                   
          conversion coefficient is determined in accordance with a                   
          formula that depends on both the magnitude and sign of the                  
          detected amount of defocus.                                                 
               Hoshino’s proposed count 3 differs from count 1 by                     
          specifically and particularly reciting that the formula for                 

                                       - 20 -                                         





Page:  Previous  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007