Ex parte JOSEPH et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 95-1599                                                            
          Application 08/062,492                                                        


          (Answer, pages 3 and 4) about the relationship of the “processor              
          machine” and the two abstract machines, appellants explain                    
          throughout the disclosure that the two abstract machines are part             
          of a change management virtual machine (CMVM) 20 (Figure 1), and              
          that the CMVM 20 is a “processor machine” that executes “said                 
          first instruction set and said second instruction set.”  In claim             
          8, the version abstract machine is the “structure” for performing             
          the claimed “functions” (Answer, page 4).  In claims 19 and 20,               
          the “plurality of said object” (Answer, pages 4 and 5) refers to              
          the objects at each of the nodes (Figure 4).  In claims 24 and                
          25, the “structure” (Answer, page 5) for performing the claimed               
          functions is the “version abstract machine” and the “config-                  
          uration abstract machine,” respectively.  The “pointer” (Answer,              
          page 5) in claims 29 and 31 is illustrated in Figure 7 wherein                
          the truck engine configuration node 540 points to version graph               
          600 for specific versions of the truck engine.  In claim 32, the              
          “collection of functions” (Answer, pages 5 and 6) is performed by             
          the version abstract machine, the configuration abstract machine              
          and the processor machine.  Thus, the claims do, in fact, set out             
          and circumscribe a particular area with a reasonable degree of                
          precision and particularity when read in light of the application             



                                           5                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007