Ex parte HOLBROOK - Page 7




          Appeal No. 95-2936                                                          
          Application 07/887,040                                                      



          the O'Dea patent (4,924,805) represents a prior art moistening              
          apparatus for moistening the glue line of an envelope flap and              
          discloses the structure and operation of portions of appellant's            
          system including the envelope transport and movable moistening              
          spray nozzle structures.  What O'Dea lacks is any teaching or               
          suggestion regarding collection of excess sprayed moistening                
          fluid and of a pump means for pumping the collected moistening              
          fluid from the collection means back to a moistening fluid supply           
          tank, as is set forth in appellant's claim 23 on appeal.                    


                    However, looking at Figure 5 of O'Dea, it is apparent             
          to us that excess spray from nozzle (250) and runoff from                   
          envelope flap (451) will travel along the inclined guide wall and           
          baffle (454) of the apparatus therein and ultimately be deposited           
          in the base portion of the housing of the moistening unit.                  
          Marzullo, Figure 10, evidences knowledge in the art concerning              
          how to deal with such excess moistening fluid runoff.  As clearly           
          seen in Marzullo, the excess moistening fluid reaching the base             
          portion of the housing therein is collected and directed into a             
          container or tank (40).  As can be seen in Figure 9 of Marzullo,            
          the collected excess moistening fluid is then pumped by a pump              


                                          7                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007