Ex parte BURGIE et al. - Page 7




          Appeal No. 95-3422                                                           
          Application 07/891,132                                                       
               grams of the silicon carbide-silicon nitride mixture                    
               which was spread level; then the center was scraped out                 
               with a flat edge scraper to provide a thin section 4 in                 
               Fig. 1.  This results in the end portions 5 having twice                
               the thickness of the center 4.  This was then followed by               
               a 77.3 gram quantity of the silicon nitride powder which                
               was uniformly spread and leveled.  The graphite mold                    
          plate                                                                        
               was put in position and the tri-layered content of the                  
               mold cavity was hot-pressed at 2,000 p.s.i. at 1,750 C forO                  
               60 minutes.                                                             
                    Electrical leads were connected to the silicon                     
               nitride-silicon carbide resistor core of the plate thus                 
               producing an insulated heating element . . . .                          
               On the other hand, referring to the reactor depicted in                 
          Fig. 1, Levin teaches (Levin, col. 5, l. 17-24):                             
               [T]he outer cylinder 12 is provided with suitable entry                 
               ports for copper or like conduits 28 which conduct                      
          current                                                                      
               for energizing graphite, “picket fence” type resistance                 
               heaters 30 surrounding the inner reactor apparatus 10.                  
               The resistance heaters 30 and the inner reactor apparatus               
               32 are separated from one another by a high temperature                 
               resistant electrical insulator 31.                                      
               We have considered the teachings of Levin and Richerson                 
          as a whole.  We fail to see why persons having ordinary skill                
          in the art would have been led by the combined teachings to                  
          insulate Levin’s energizing graphite, “picket fence” type                    
          resistance heaters 30 from the graphite or other carbon                      
          reactor material which forms the walls of Levin’s reactor 32                 

                                        - 7 -                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007