Ex parte LEE et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 95-3497                                                          
          Application 08/158,649                                                      


          the input 8-bit offset-128 binary value (col. 16, lines 8-13).              
          Also, when SPLIT is true, the AND gate 454 is disabled, thereby             
          disconnecting carry-out terminal CO  of adder circuit 452 from              
                                             0                                        
          carry-in terminal CI  of adder circuit 450.  Appellants concede             
                              1                                                       
          (Brief at pages 3-4) that                                                   
               given two operands X and Y, the X operand being divided into           
               sub-operands X1 and X2 and the Y operand being dividable               
               into sub-operands Y1 and Y2, the device taught by Patti, et            
               al. computes either [X ±Y ] and [X ±Y ] or X±Y.  The choice1  1       2  2                                  
               of whether the sums or differences are performed or whether            
               partial word or whole word operations are performed is                 
               determined by the specific instruction.                                
          The examiner agrees with Appellants that the Patti references do            
          not disclose "means, responsive to a third instruction, for                 
          generating the difference divided by two of each sub-word in said           
          X word and the corresponding sub-word in said Y word, the result            
          thereof determining said corresponding sub-word of said result              
          word."  The examiner maintains that this                                    
               feature is old and well known in the art.  Moreover, the               
               common knowledge and common sense of the person of ordinary            
               skill in the art at the time the invention was made to use             
               the "difference divided by two" in . . . Patti et al.'s                
               adder.  [Answer at 3.]                                                 
          The examiner additionally relies on the "well known fact in the             
          digital computing art that to enable 'divided by two' to be                 
          performed more quickly, a shifter could be used to perform the              
          desired function" (Answer at 5).                                            

                                        - 5 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007