Ex parte MANDULEY - Page 5




          Appeal No. 95-4184                                                          
          Application 07/813,080                                                      

               program 14.  The GRANT LICENSE request message is                      
               transmitted to the licensing policy module 15, which                   
               notifies the operating system of the request.                          
          The policy module receiving the GRANT LICENSE request (also                 
          shown as step 50 in figures 4A-1) corresponds to claimed                    
          step (a).      "The operating system 13, in turn, passes the                
          request, along with the system marketing model of the specific              
          system 16 being used by the user, to the license management                 
          facility 10 which determines whether use of the program is                  
          permitted under the license."  Col. 3, lines 47-51.  The                    
          system is identified by the system marketing model (SMM) code               
          (col. 2, lines 60-62).  Thus, the action of the operating                   
          system sending the request and the SMM to the license                       
          management facility (also shown in step 52 in figure 4A-1)                  
          corresponds to claimed step (b) and the "transmitting" step in              
          claimed step (c).                                                           
               In Robert, if the license management facility determines               
          that the usage of the desired licensed program is permitted                 
          under usage restrictions "the license management facility                   
          transmits a usage approved response to the operating                        
          system 13" (col. 4, lines 31-33).  The step of the license                  
          management facility transmitting a positive response to the                 

                                        - 5 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007