Ex parte COMROE et al. - Page 8




          Appeal No. 96-1386                                                          
          Application 08/030,937                                                      


          not teach or suggest a two-way dispatch radio communication unit            
          having a microphone and a control means for controlling operation           
          of the radio transceiver means in at least a first and second               
          discrete mode, wherein in the first discrete mode, the radio                
          transceiver means transmits audio messages and in the second                





          mode, the radio transceiver means transmits the video information           
          and the push-to-talk switch means for selecting the first and               
          second discrete modes of operation as recited in Appellants                 
          claims.  Brown teaches to those skilled in the art how to modify            
          a typical two-way dispatch radio communication unit to become a             
          dedicated two-way dispatch radio communication unit that only has           
          one mode in which video information is transmitted.  See columns            
          1 and 2.  Brown does not teach a modification in which typical              
          two-way dispatch radio communication retains its original                   
          function of having a discrete mode for transmitting audible                 
          messages.  We agree that Brown does mention a push-to-talk switch           
          of a typical two-way dispatch radio in column 5, lines 52 and 53.           
          However, in column 5, lines 35-68, Brown teaches that the push-             
          to-talk switch is modified so that the PIA 34 keys the                      

                                          8                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007