Ex parte CULLEN - Page 4




          Appeal No. 96-4004                                                           
          Application 08/342,603                                                       


          meet the limitations in independent claims 10 and 16 relating                
          to the silage density control means.  These limitations                      
          require, inter alia, that the control means include a                        
          plurality of horizontally spaced-apart density bars which are                
          secured to an elongated, horizontally disposed, rotatable                    
          shaft for selective movement within the flow of silage                       
          material.  Although Cox’s pivot panels 140 correspond                        
          generally to the claimed density control means, they lack the                
          spaced-apart bar configuration specified by claims 10 and 16.                
          As a result of this difference in configuration, Cox’s pivot                 
          panels 140 also fail to control silage density in the                        
          particular manner set forth in these claims.                                 
               Eggenmuller discloses a machine and method for pressing                 
          loose feed material into a mass having a desired density.  The               
          machine 2 includes “a receiving chamber 3 in which pressing                  
          tools 4 are arranged which press the feed into a forming                     
          channel and consists of a carriage with rollers 6.  The                      
          forming channel 5 has in cross-section the shape of the mass                 
          of material 7 to be produced” (column 5, lines 9 through 13).                
          As depicted in Figures 1 through 3, the pressing tools 4                     
          appear to consist of a plurality of horizontally spaced-apart                
                                         -4-                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007