Ex parte ANTHIAS - Page 5




          Appeal No. 97-1227                                                          
          Application 08/163,416                                                      

          According to the appellant (reply brief at 3), "[e]ach claim                
          requires storage of the respective application program window               
          display data and corresponding action field in the local                    
          processor memory, and storage of remaining display data in the              
          remote processor memory."  The appellant states (Reply at 4):               
          "[I]n Eagen et al., there is no division of storage, as                     
          claimed by the appellant." [Emphasis added].                                
               The appellant’s argument is misplaced.  Claim 1 has no                 
          language which actually requires any "division of storage."                 
          Both the host processor and the local processor can store the               
          entirety of the display data and that would still be within                 
          the defined scope of claim 1.  All that is required is that                 
          the local processor memory stores certain display data and the              
          host processor stores certain remaining display data.  Nothing              
          precludes either processor from storing additional data                     
          including data already stored in the other processor.                       
               Citing column 9, lines 26-29 and column 9, line 68 to                  
          column 10, line 2, the examiner finds that Eagen teaches                    
          transmitting only the desired window panel contents to the                  
          local processor from the host processor (Supp. Answer at 5).                
          Citing column 8, lines 29-32, the examiner finds that                       

                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007