Ex parte ANDREA et al. - Page 11




          Appeal No. 97-2734                                                           
          Application 08/394,067                                                       



                    means for biasing said supporting means                            
                    to provide a dynamic support for said                              
                    handgrip while said orthopedic crutches                            
                    [sic] is in use.                                                   


                    In somewhat different terms, independent claim 12 on               
          appeal defines an orthopedic crutch which comprises a pair of                
          vertical supports (e.g., 26); an upper cross-member (e.g., 17)               
          rigidly connected to said vertical supports at an upper end                  
          forming an armpit support; a support leg (e.g., 16), rigidly                 
          connected intermediate the opposing ends of the vertical                     
          supports; a handgrip (e.g., 24); and                                         
                    means for dynamically supporting said                              
                    handgrip while said orthopedic crutch is                           
                    in use to provide a movable support for                            
                    both upward and downward movement of said                          
                    handgrip.                                                          


                    In the examiner's view the crutch of Stein includes                
          a handgrip as defined in appellants' claims 1 and 12, with the               


          structure seen best in Figure 3 and 4 of Stein being                         
          responsive to the "means" clauses of claims 1 and 12.                        
          However, we share appellants' view that Stein's crutch                       
                                          11                                           





Page:  Previous  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007