Ex parte ARABIA, JR. et al. - Page 4




          Appeal No. 97-3297                                                          
          Application 08/390,973                                                      



                    All three of the claims before us include a molded                
          plastic operating lever having a bushing portion “integrally                
          molded in one piece continuous molded together construction with            
          the molded plastic lever and having a bore for receiving the rod,           





          retaining fingers molded integral with the bushing portion” and             
          “a frangible web molded integral in connection between the                  
          bushing portion and the lever.”  In other words, the basic                  
          construction set forth in the claims requires that the operating            
          lever, the bushing portion, the rod retaining fingers and the               
          frangible web be molded together into an integral one piece                 
          continuous structure.                                                       
                    In Nix, a retainer bushing 10 is installed into a bore            
          in pushrod 35 by “pressing” (column 6, line 18).  There is                  
          nothing to suggest that these components are otherwise attached             
          together, much less that they are integrally molded in a                    
          continuous structure, as is required by the appellants’ claims.             
          In fact, in the preferred embodiment, Nix indicates that they are           
          of different materials (note the cross-hatching in the drawings             
          and see  column 3, lines 40-45).  The examiner recognizes this,             
                                          4                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007