Ex parte LU et al. - Page 4




          Appeal No. 96-1188                                                          
          Application No. 08/240,800                                                  


          hydrogen sulfide from the reactor, (3) forming bisulfite in                 
          the solution by absorbing additional sulfur dioxide after                   
          removal of the hydrogen sulfide gas, and (4) removing the                   
          aqueous bisulfite-containing solution from the reactor.                     
          Although Talonen discloses at column 4 that bisulfite and                   
          hydrogen sulfide are products of some of the reactions that                 
          occur during the introduction of sulfur dioxide into a sulfide              
          solution, neither Talonen nor any of the other cited                        
          references provides a teaching of the sequence of steps                     
          defined by the process presently on appeal.  Canada '378                    
          discloses a process for inhibiting the emission of hydrogen                 
          sulfide during the absorption of sulfur dioxide in a sulfide                
          solution and fails to teach the generation of bisulfite.                    
          Talonen, in the paragraph bridging columns 4 and 5, teaches                 
          that bisulfite is first produced when sulphur dioxide is                    
          introduced into a sulphide solution and, then, after a certain              
          amount of sulphur dioxide is absorbed by the sodium sulphide,               
          plenty of hydrogen sulphide is released from the solution.                  
          Also, Talonen does not disclose removing bisulfite as a                     
          product but, rather, elemental sulfur is the product of the                 
          Talonen process.                                                            

                                         -4-                                          




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007