Ex parte GOLDENBERG - Page 11




          Appeal No. 96-2043                                                          
          Application 07/990,514                                                      


          4, line 8.                                                                  
               In short, Seppala teaches forming a composite pulse                    
          having a temporal time duration )t=N .320 nsec as an                        
                                              B                                       
          intermediate step in the process of forming a high power laser              
          beam output.  The duration of the output beam, however, is 20               
          nsec.  As appellant points out at page 8 of the brief, Seppala              
          suggests that the invention may be useful in inertial                       
          confinement fusion.                                                         




               We have carefully considered the collective teachings of               
          Hussein, L'Esperance, Guerder, Davies and Seppala.  However,                
          we fail to perceive any suggestion in the collective teachings              
          of                                                                          
          the references to couple a pulsed XeCl Excimer laser having a               
          pulse duration between 100 nsec and 3000 nsec to the proximal               
          end of a fiber optic waveguide in an angioplasty system which               
          would have motivated one of ordinary skill to make such a                   
          change in the catheter device shown by Hussein, except the                  
          hindsight accorded one who first viewed the appellant’s                     
          disclosure.  This, of course, is impermissible.  See In re                  
                                         11                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007