Ex parte TANIAI et al. - Page 8




          Appeal No. 96-2742                                                            
          Application No. 08/311,371                                                    


          recording and reproducing unit sense the presence and absence                 
          of the carrying means.  When                                                  


          the carrying means finishes loading the recording medium into                 
          the loading means, the carrying means moves away from the                     
          loading unit, which the detectors sense, and the detectors                    
          send a signal to the read/write processing unit of the                        
          recording and reproducing unit to indicate that the first                     
          component is done.  In other words, contrary to the examiner's                
          assertion, no signal must be sent between the two elements, as                
          detectors in the recording and reproducing means supply the                   
          necessary information.  Therefore, we find no electrical                      
          signals sent from the carrying means to the recording and                     
          reproducing unit to indicate that the recording medium is                     
          ready for loading.                                                            
               As to the electrical instruction signal from the carrying                
          means for claim 7 and the electrical ejection end signals from                
          the carrying means for claims 14, 15, and 17, the examiner                    
          points to no further sections of the admitted prior art to                    
          meet these limitations.  As explained above, we find no                       
          electrical instruction signals sent from the carrying means to                
                                           8                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007