Ex parte RICHARD et al. - Page 9




          Appeal No. 96-2894                                                          
          Application 08/742,974                                                      

          The examiner further states (EA7-8):  "However, as admitted                 
          by Appellant, Anderson [sic] does show that programs are                    
          transmitted over the network.  Why such transmission is not                 
          a 'distributed delivery' Appellant fails to point out."                     
               The limitation to "a course delivery system distributed                
          over said at least one workstation, said servers, and said                  
          main computer" is considered to broadly read on Andersen.                   
          In Andersen, a plurality of instructional programs are                      
          transferred from a central main frame computer                              
          (corresponding to the claimed "main computer") to a mass                    
          storage device 14 in a cluster subsystem 10 (corresponding                  
          to the claimed "server") over a link 15 (col. 6,                            
          lines 41-50) which maintains a number of entire                             
          instructional programs in a high speed buffer 12 (col. 6,                   
          lines 19-27) and segments of the program are transmitted to                 
          a requesting processor station (corresponding to the claimed                
          "workstation") as needed (col. 5, lines 56-58).  Since the                  
          programs or parts of the programs reside at the central                     
          computer, the cluster subsystem, and the processor, the                     
          course delivery system is "distributed."  Unlike claim 1,                   
          there are no limitations that the distributed delivery                      

                                        - 9 -                                         





Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007