Ex parte SHIM - Page 8




          Appeal No. 96-3234                                                          
          Application 08/184,446                                                      



          Examiner's position is set forth in Paper No. 4.  Turning to                
          Paper No. 4,                                                                


          the Examiner states that the admitted prior art in Appellant's              
          specification on pages 1 through 3 shows that there are 8 bit               
          data and a one bit pointer.  The Examiner argues that the                   
          memory is arranged to store by byte so that the pointer is                  
          stored in a byte location thereby wasting the other 7 bits.                 
          The Examiner argues that Ozaki discloses a system where the                 
          pointer memory is equal to the number of bits of the pointer.               
                    Appellant argues on page 23 of the appeal brief that              
          the admitted prior art and Ozaki fail to teach a                            
          writing/reading control signal generating unit for generating               
          the respective writing and reading control signals of first                 
          and second memories by receiving the writing and reading                    
          control signals and responding to a data point differentiating              
          signal as recited in claim 1.  On page 27 of the appeal brief,              
          Appellant argues that the admitted prior art and Ozaki fail to              
          teach or suggest a data bus driving unit for driving an m + n               
          bit data bus operatively connected to said memory bi-                       

                                          8                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007