Ex parte GAULTIER et al. - Page 8




          Appeal No. 1996-3362                                                        
          Application No. 08/258,601                                                  


          selection between these two modes is done by pressing a key on              
          the keyboard and not a pressure-activated switch on the                     
          displaying mean.  See column 7, lines 45 through 49.  We also               
          find that Levine teaches a pressure-activated switch, 22e,                  
          disclosed in column 6, lines 31 through 68.  However, the                   
          pressure-activated switch is disclosed to emulate the                       
          functions of a one button mouse as found on the Apple                       
          MacIntosh Computer which is used not to select between modes                
          for the cursor but instead used in the normal mouse click                   
          function.  Thus, we find that Levine fails to teach using a                 
          pressure sensitive switch to select between the relative                    
          pointing mode and the absolute pointing mode of the cursor.                 
               Turning to Faulkerson, we fail to find that Faulkerson                 
          teaches using a pressure switch, in which a predetermined                   
          threshold is determined, to select between two modes.  In                   
          particular Faulkerson merely has a plurity of switches 26a                  
          through 26e shown in Figure 1 which are used to operate either              
          the optical scanner or the computer mouse.  We fail to find                 
          that Faulkerson teaches selecting between two modes by                      
          comparing a force with a predetermined threshold.                           
               On pages 9 through 12, Appellants argue that the                       
                                          8                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007