Ex parte BRAND et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 97-1973                                                           
          Application No. 08/248,003                                                   


          example, Figure 6.                                                           
               Von Bolhar discloses a dredge digging structure having                  
          buckets 81 mounted on a plurality of link bodies 51 of an                    
          endless chain 21.  In order to mount the buckets 81 on the                   
          link bodies 51, the side walls of the buckets are provided                   
          with lugs 86 and 87 having reenforcing flanges 88 and 89 and                 
          terminate in bosses 90 and 91.  When assembled to the chain,                 
          the bosses 90 and 91 are aligned with bosses 93 and 94 located               
          on the lateral faces of the link bodies 51.  See col. 4, lines               
          31-43.                                                                       
               Appellants argue, inter alia, that none of the applied                  
          references teach "an upright edge 'engaging and supporting' a                
          rib as recited" (brief, page 6).   In response, the examiner4                                            
          argues that                                                                  
               Whisler places upright edges on the lower wheel and Von                 
               Bolhar changes the location of Gray's ribs to be between                
               the chain and the upright edges, thus allowing the                      
               upright edges to engage and support the ribs. (answer,                  
               page 5)                                                                 


          As indicated above, the examiner asserts that one of ordinary                

               4Claim 4 actually calls for "upright edges on the lower wheel engaging  
          and supporting the ribs" (emphasis supplied).                                
                                          6                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007