Ex parte BRENNER et al. - Page 17




          Appeal No. 98-1012                                                          
          Serial No. 08/117,342                                                       




          Examiner cites Edberg to overcome Manafi=s deficiencies.                    


               According to the examiner, Edberg teaches Aan assay for                
          the simultaneous detection of E. coli and other coliform                    
          bacteria@ (second supplemental examiner=s answer, paper no.                 
          48.8, page 3) with agents to suppress the growth of Gram-                   
          positive bacteria,                                                          


          yeast (which are eukaryotic, not bacteria), and Aagents to                  
          suppress bacterial growth other than coliform bacteria                      
          (Edberg, col. 5, lines 29-33 through col. 6, lines 58-62)@                  
          (second supplemental examiner=s answer, paper no. 48.8, page                
          3). Edberg=s suppressing agents are said to prevent                         
          interference in the assay due to the other organisms B                      
          reducing false positive and false negative incidences and                   
          making the assay more accurate and reproducible. In other                   
          words, according to the examiner, Edberg suggests inhibiting                
          the growth of any other organism than the particular bacteria               




                                          17                                          





Page:  Previous  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007