Ex parte STOY et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1999-0072                                                        
          Application 08/692,466                                                      


          system such as a gas turbine engine” (Abstract).  The flow                  
          control system includes a flow control subsystem 14 comprising              
          a throttling control valve 18 and a mass flow measurement                   
          subsystem 16 comprising a flow restriction element 22 and                   
          transducers 26 and 24 for measuring the pressure upstream of                
          the restriction and the pressure drop across the restriction.               
               As implicitly conceded by the examiner, none of these                  
          references teaches or would have suggested the subject matter               





          recited in the claims on appeal.  Nevertheless, the examiner                
          has concluded that                                                          
               [i]t would have been obvious at the time of the . .                    
               . invention to one of ordinary skill in the art to                     
               modify the control system of Nogami by including the                   
               phase splitter of Stoy as a source of fluids for the                   
               two components (A and B; Nogami) in order to provide                   
               a control system for providing desired steam quality                   
               ratios; further, it would have been obvious at the                     
               time of the . . . invention to one of ordinary skill                   
               in the art to modify the flow sensors of Nogami by                     
               substituting the flow sensors as taught by Statler                     
               in order to provide flow sensors that only require                     
               pressure and pressure drop readings across an                          
               orifice and further are reliable and cost-efficient                    
               [final rejection, page 2].                                             

                                         -5-                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007