Ex parte STEELEY - Page 7




          Appeal No. 99-0633                                         Page 7           
          Application No. 08/880,247                                                  


          As the slot or opening (170) for receiving the key blade is                 
          located between the hinges affixing one frame half (a closure)              
          to the other frame half (a housing), the opening (170) is not               
          formed in an endwall, with planar sidewalls extending between               
          the endwall and the closure, as required by claim 1.                        
               Further, as conceded by the examiner, Levine lacks an                  
          insert comprising foldable material "having a medial slot                   
          formed therein for cooperative alignment with said slot of                  
          said endwall" as required in claim 1.  We have reviewed the                 
          disclosure of Corwin and do not find therein any suggestion to              
          provide such an insert in the Levine device in place of the                 
          two indicia plates.                                                         
               Corwin discloses a carrying case for carrying keys, the                
          keys being retained in a retracted position inside the                      
          carrying case by means of a deflectable bar (44) having a dog               
          (49) which cooperates with a slot (28) in a key-carrying clip               
          (21) folded about a key.  To release a key to an extended                   
          position as shown in the center of Figure 1, the user                       
          depresses the end (48) of the bar (44), thereby forcing the                 
          dog (49) out of the slot (28).  The                                         









Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007