Ex parte ZLOTNIK et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1999-1816                                       Page 5           
          Application No. 08/370,540                                                  


          of the cabinet with a series of lock tabs 10, 11, 12 which are              
          inaccessible such that the housing can only be opened by                    
          someone with a special tool.  Zlotnik teaches (column 1, lines              
          56-68) that                                                                 
               Preferably the frame is generally C-shaped having an                   
               integrally formed back plate, top plate and bottom plate.              
               The lock tabs are mounted on the top and bottom plates                 
               and also on the inner surfaces of the housing near its                 
               back edge. The lock tabs on the top and bottom plates                  
               engage the lock tabs on the inner surfaces of the housing              
               to prevent the housing from being pulled forward and                   
               removed. Only by depressing the front tip of both the top              
               plate and the bottom plate, preferably with a special                  
               tool, can the lock tabs on both plates be shifted to                   
               permit the lock tabs on the housing to be disengaged,                  
               thereby permitting housing to be removed completely.                   

               In addition, Zlotnik discloses (column 2, lines 49-52)                 
          that frame 3 (including its back plate 13, top plate 14 and                 
          bottom plate 15) can be constructed of any kind of durable,                 
          flexible and tamper-resistant material and that polypropylene               
          is a good example of such a material.  Zlotnik further teaches              
          (column 3, line 64, to column 4, line 6) that                               
               The upper surface of the bottom plate 15 is adapted to                 
               slidably receive a base tray 16 which preferably contains              
               the deodorant.  This permits the spent deodorant to be                 
               replaced very easily. The base tray 16 is multifunctional              
               and can accept liquid deodorant canisters, square porous               
               membrane deodorant bars or hardened cylindrical deodorant              
               discs.                                                                 







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007