Ex parte QUANDT - Page 6




          Appeal No. 1999-2364                                                        
          Application No. 08/562,816                                                  


               Rejection (2) also will not be sustained as to claim 18,               
          and claim 19 dependent thereon, because neither North,                      
          Schuetze nor Hoss teaches or suggests the use of "a plurality               
          of spaced, in line snap fasteners" as recited in claim 18.                  
          Rejection (3)                                                               
               Since the secondary references applied in this rejection               
          do not render obvious the differences between parent claim 1                
          and the disclosure of North noted in the discussion of                      
          rejection (1), supra, rejection (3) will not be sustained.                  
          Rejection (4)                                                               
               This rejection will not be sustained as to claims 6 and                
          9, for the same reason as stated in the foregoing paragraph                 
          concerning rejection (3).                                                   
               Independent claim 13 recites, inter alia, that portions                
          of the bottom sheet top face and top sheet bottom face                      
          "comprise sweatshirt fleece."  The examiner states the basis                
          of this rejection on page 5 of the final rejection as:                      
                    North fails to discloses the top sheet                            
                    having a bottom face comprised of fleece.                         
                    Young discloses a top sheet 12 having a                           
                    bottom face comprised of a soft plush                             
                    fabric such as wool or cotton (col. 3 lines                       
                    19-24).  It would have been obvious to                            
                    place the fabric surface as taught by Young                       
                                          6                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007