Ex parte GROSSMAN et al. - Page 4




          Appeal No. 1997-0227                                                        
          Application No. 08/113,147                                                  

               monomer such as butadiene or a mixture of butadiene                    
               and a core comonomer, is present in a dispersed                        
               second phase, resulting in polymer as a dispersed                      
               solid phase. . . .                                                     
                    For the microgel binders used in practicing the                   
               invention, the butadiene is only partially                             
               polymerized at this point.  It is preferred that                       
               less than about 95% by weight of the butadiene                         
               monomer is polymerized, more preferably 60 to 90% is                   
               polymerized.  At this point, a monomer having acid                     
               functionality is added to the reacting mixture.                        
               This monomer polymerizes with the remaining                            
               butadiene monomer to form a thin shell on the                          
               polybutadiene core.                                                    
          A microgel produced by this process is also described in                    
          Example 1.  See Specification, p. 25 (polymerization of core                
          was allowed to proceed until approximately 85% of the                       
          butadiene had polymerized; thereafter, methacrylic acid was                 
          added to produce a shell of poly(butadiene/methacrylic acid));              
          see also Specification, p. 30.                                              
               Therefore, in view of the specification, we interpret                  
          "unpolymerized elastomeric monomer from the core" to mean that              
          monomer present during polymerization of the core but which                 
          remains unreacted after polymerization of the core has ceased.              
          See In re Prater, 415 F.2d 1393, 1404-05, 162 USPQ 541, 550-51              
          (CCPA 1969) (claims cannot be read in a vacuum but instead                  
          must be read in the light of the specification).                            
                                     Discussion                                       
                                          4                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007