Ex parte GIDDINGS et al. - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1998-1509                                                        
          Application No. 07/811,509                                                  


               The problem, as we view it, is that Launey does not                    
          specify or suggest that such control is effected by the                     
          central processor accessing “a set of addressable control                   
          functions” wherein that set of addressable control functions                
          is in the operating environment controllers (i.e., the                      
          lighting and music controllers) and arranged so that the                    
          single signal from the central processor causes the plurality               
          of operating environment controllers to furnish operating                   
          point signals to cause apparatuses to operate in concert, as                
          claimed.  While each of independent claims 1, 12 and 28                     
          describes the invention in a slightly different manner, each                
          claim requires, in one form or another, the “set of                         
          addressable control functions,” stored in the operating                     
          environment controllers and accessible by a state vector                    
          signal, to be arranged so that a common signal will address                 
          the control functions to cause the apparatuses controlled by                
          the operating environment controllers to function in an                     
          integrated manner, or in concert.                                           
               There is no indication in Launey that the operating                    
          environment controllers in Launey operate in such a manner so               
          as to include a “set of addressable control functions” in the               
                                         -5-                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007