Ex parte RICHARDS - Page 5




          Appeal No. 1998-1981                                                        
          Application No. 08/695,899                                                  


               We note that Appellant's claim 9 recites "[a] volume                   
          current conveyance means . . . for conveying a volume current               
          from said portion of said insulator, through said volume                    
          current conveyance means, and for avoiding high electric field              
          strengths in said means and on said portion of said                         
          insulator."  We note that Appellant's Fig. 1 shows the volume               
          current conveyance means as Element 12.  See pages 4 and 5 of               
          Appellant's specification.                                                  
               We note that in column 2, lines 63 and 64, Tsuzuki                     
          teaches that Element 4 is a semi-conducting glaze.                          
          Furthermore, we note in column 3, lines 8 through 11, that                  
          Tsuzuki teaches that the Figure shows the thickness of the                  
          semi-conducting glaze 4 on an enlarged scale.  Thus, the semi-              
          conducting glaze 4 shown in the Figure has a very small                     
          thickness.  From this disclosure and from the Figure, we fail               
          to find that this semi-conducting glaze 4 which has a very                  
          thin thickness meets the Appellant's claimed volume current                 
          conveyance means because the semi-conducting                                
          glaze 4 is unable to convey a volume current from the said                  
          insulator. Furthermore, the semi-conducting glaze 4 is not                  

                                          5                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007