Ex parte JOHNSON - Page 21




          Appeal No. 2000-0873                                                        
          Application No. 08/975,983                                                  


          mural, (3) a plurality of color samples provided in a second                
          tangible medium distinct from the picture and having the same               
          colors as the paints of the mural, and (4) a third tangible                 
          medium identifying a name of a paint manufacturer line of                   
          paints for use in painting the mural.                                       
               As to items (1) and (2) of the claimed kit, for the                    
          reasons discussed above in connection with the rejection of                 
          claims 66, 67, 75 and 76, it would have been obvious in view                
          of Mayer to adopt the picture painting kit of Milne to allow a              
          user to reproduce a scene as a large-scale wall mural, and in               
          the process provide a kit having items (1) and (2).                         
          Concerning item (3), DePauw relates to a device for teaching                
          color mixing in a coordinated manner, and includes a mixing                 
          tray 10, a plurality of paints in squeeze bottles, and a                    
          mixing chart (Figure 6) having a                                            




          color scale and indicia thereon for demonstrating how colors                
          can be mixed to obtain other colors.  Based on Milne’s                      
          teaching of including in the kit instructions that inform the               
          user of how to mix paints (column 3, lines 30-35), and                      
                                          21                                          





Page:  Previous  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007