Ex parte WASTI et al. - Page 8




          Appeal No. 1998-0931                                       Page 8           
          Application No. 08/139,619                                                  


          [the] players independently inputting the information to the                
          non-master dart games or receivers (50)."                                   
               Appellants assert (brief, page 11) that the rejection                  
          does not address the invention as a whole.  Appellants argue                
          that both Hedges and Tillery teach displays used to operate                 
          their respective games, and that the displays are interactive               
          and player operated.  According to appellants (id.), if a                   
          person of ordinary skill in the art sought to increase the                  
          number of terminals in a gaming system such as Hedges, "the                 
          terminals would all be useful for operating the game as parts               
          of an interactive station at which data is entered and data is              
          displayed."  With respect to Tillery, appellants point out                  
          that Tillery (col. 5, lines 57-59) discloses the non-master                 
          dart games 50 to "include visual displays for providing                     
          players with directions, game scores, and the like."                        
          Appellants conclude (id. at pages 11 and  12) that the                      
          examiner has not met the burden of presenting a prima facie                 
          case of obviousness because the cited references lack "the                  
          appendage of a display controller and associated auxiliary                  
          noninteractive displays to a lottery network of interactively               
          operable terminals including displays."                                     







Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007