Ex parte TOGASHI - Page 6




          Appeal No. 1998-2933                                                         
          Application 08/439,082                                                       

               Claim 1 recites "a control unit for controlling a                       
          receptive state of said signal receiver in response to the                   
          processed remote control signal," but does not recite that the               
          receptive state is between active/inactive                                   
          (continuous/standby) modes.  The APA discloses switching                     
          between continuous/standby modes in response to a detected                   
          electric field of the remote control signal.  Claim 1 recites                
          that the receptive state is controlled "in response to the                   
          processed remote control signal," which does not require                     
          control in response to identifying the idling information.                   
          Claim 1 does not exclude use of an electric field detector                   
          (compare claim 11) and so the "processed remote control                      
          signal" could be the signal processed by the electric field                  
          detector in the APA.  While the control unit detects a                       
          transmission "by identifying the idling information," it is                  
          not recited how this detection is used, if at all, to control                
          the signal receiver except that it is inferred to be part of                 
          the processing of the remote control signal.  In fact, claim 1               
          does not specify that the idling information precedes the data               
          information so that it could be used to change the receptive                 
          state for receiving the data information; compare claim 6                    

                                        - 6 -                                          





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007