Ex parte COOPER - Page 6




          Appeal No. 1999-0294                                                        
          Application No. 08/727,256                                                  


          enabled during the read operation.  The examiner bases this                 
          belief on Arroyo’s disclosure of the ECC generator being used               
          only when the reading operation is performed [answer-pages 4-               
          5].                                                                         
               To whatever extent the examiner statement may be accurate              
          in the sense of the ECC in Arroyo being “in use” or “not in                 
          use,” during certain times during the processing in Arroyo,                 
          this is not the same as the “disabling” and “enabling” of ECC               
          capabilities, as claimed in the instant application.  The                   
          instant claims require that ECC capabilities are disabled.                  
          That means that even if the ECC capabilities would normally be              
          invoked at some point, they cannot be because the ECC                       
          capabilities are disabled.  It is more than a matter of the                 
          ECC generator simply not being used at a particular time                    
          because, in the instant claimed invention, if the ECC                       
          capabilities were not “disabled,” as claimed, then the                      
          subsequent writing of the test pattern may cause the ECC                    
          capabilities to be invoked.  However, the instant claimed                   
          invention specifically requires the step of disabling the ECC               
          capabilities of the memory controller before the subsequent                 
          writing of a test pattern and a first ECC code to a selected                
                                         6–                                           





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007