Ex parte RECKTENWALD et al. - Page 6




          Appeal No. 1999-1780                                                         
          Application No. 08/651,630                                                   


                    displaying means for displaying the identified                     
               item to the customer . . . .                                            
               We find that the credit card reader 34 of Lohrey                        
          constitutes a “customer identifying means” for identifying a                 
          customer in response to data supplied directly by the customer,              
          as called for in claim 28.  We further find that the kiosk-like              
          retail outlet structure 10 of Lohrey inherently includes an                  
          “item identifying means” for identifying an item to be picked up             
          from a database based upon the identification of the customer by             
          the “customer identifying means,” as called for in claim 28, in              
          that when a customer comes to Lohrey’s kiosk to, for example,                
          pick up laundry or dry cleaning that had previously been dropped             
          off for cleaning, the item retrieval device of the kiosk (column             
          5, lines 56-68) that retrieves items from the kiosk’s storage                
          area for delivery to the customer must inherently interact with              
          some means that identify and associate a particular item in the              
          storage area with a particular customer’s order.  In this                    
          regard, see column 9, lines 61-66, and column 10, lines 31-40.               
          The examiner has not pointed out, and it is not apparent to us,              
          where Lohrey discloses that the kiosk thereof includes “display              
          means” for displaying to the customer the particular item called             

                                          6                                            





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007