Ex parte CROWLEY et al. - Page 11




          Appeal No. 1999-2216                                                        
          Application 08/805,399                                                      

          loadsource DASD from the remote site to the local site for                  
          attachment to the replacement computer system                               
          (specification: p. 2, lines 1-18).  Thus, the rejection                     
          starts with remote IPL, which is a different kind of method                 
          than the local IPL method of claim 1.                                       
               The Examiner finds that "the applicant's admitted prior                
          art does not teach the use of indicators representing                       
          whether the local DASD can be used, nor the specifics of                    
          copying the data from the remote location to the local DASD"                
          (EA4).                                                                      
               At best, the APA implies the first step of "replacing                  
          said damaged local loadsource direct access storage device                  
          with a replacement local loadsource direct access storage                   
          device."  None of the other steps of setting, copying,                      
          resetting, and performing an IPL are taught or suggested by                 
          the APA.                                                                    
               The Examiner finds (FR2-3):                                            
                    Shinjo teaches a system and method for recovering                 
               from a failure associated with a local (main) storage                  
               device by allowing a mirrored backup storage device to                 
               be utilized.  The system allows the data in the backup                 
               device to be copied into the local storage device, when                
               the local device is not to be used, based on an                        
               indicator stored in the backup memory device which                     
               indicates whether or not the data in the local or main                 
                                       - 11 -                                         





Page:  Previous  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007