ALTHAUS V. OLDROYD - Page 13




          Interference No. 104,158                                                    



          pins 1a.  On the opposite end of the pins 8, mounted by pivots              
          8a                                                                          


          is a cartridge support platform 13 provided with rails 16 for               
          receiving a blade containing cartridge 17.  Although the                    
          translation of Ishida refers to the mounting as a four-bar                  
          linkage at 4, paragraph 3, Ishida is not a four-bar linkage as              
          claimed and as disclosed in Terry.  The razor of Ishida does                
          not pivot about an axis but shifts or translates as a unit                  
          always remaining parallel                                                   
          to the hemispherical base 2.  According to Althaus, Ishida has              
          been cited to teach a linkage connecting the cartridge to the               
          handle with the linkage lying in the correct plane.  Be that                
          as it may, Ishida differs from the claimed invention in not                 
          showing                                                                     
          the claimed four-bar linkage, in not showing the correct                    
          pivotal movement, and in not showing a pivot axis on or below               
          the surface being shaved.                                                   
                    We are in agreement with Althaus and both parties’                
          experts as to the level of skill in this art.  The level of                 


                                          13                                          





Page:  Previous  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007