Ex Parte CELIK - Page 9



          Appeal No. 2000-0467                                                        
          Application 08/511,645                                                      

               performing a service with respect to said first object                 
               if said first object is a service object; and                          
               moving the representation of the first object from said                
               first location to a new location associated with said                  
               second object if said second object is a container                     
               object, regardless of a source of the first object.                    
               In reviewing Appellant’s disclosure to understand                      
          Appellant’s claim limitations, we note on pages 6-8 of the                  
          specification that Appellant defines the service object and the             
          container object.  Further, Appellant also uses examples to                 
          define a first object and a second object, original locations and           
          destination objects (i.e., the first and second locations).                 
          Specifically, Appellant discloses,                                          
               Figure 3A illustrates some examples of different types                 
               of container objects that can serve as destinations for                
               a drag-and-drop operation.  Referring thereto, a window                
               52 contains a file 54 which the user has selected with                 
               a cursor.  This file can be dragged to another window                  
               56 on the desktop.  Alternatively, it can be dragged to                
               a folder 58, which could reside within a window or on                  
               the desktop itself.  As a third alternative, the file                  
               54 can be dragged into a text document 60 which might                  
               be displayed in another window.  Each of the objects to                
               which the file 54 is moved in the examples of Figure                   
               3A, namely the window 56, the folder 58 and the                        
               document 60, is a ‘container’ object.  These objects                   
               have the ability to embed objects within their                         
               contents.  (Emphasis added).  See page 6, line 28 to                   
               page 7, line 6 of Appellant’s specification.                           


                                          9                                           




Page:  Previous  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007