Ex Parte CELIK - Page 11



          Appeal No. 2000-0467                                                        
          Application 08/511,645                                                      

          (for example printing or word counting) on the first object                 
          wherein the object remains intact and is not consumed by the                
          service) or a container object (i.e., an object to which the file           
          is moved such as a window, folder or document); second)                     
          performing a service with respect to said first object if said              
          second object is a service object (i.e., a printer); and, third)            
          moving the representation of the first object from said first               
          location to a new location associated with said second object if            
          said second object is a container object (i.e., a folder),                  
          regardless of a source of the first object.                                 
               Upon careful review of Berry, we find that Berry clearly               
          teaches the step of “determining whether the second object is               
          either a service object which performs a service that provides a            
          computational result on data or a container object.”  In                    
          particular, we find that Berry discloses this limitation when               
          defining that the second object can have either container                   
          behavior (i.e., folder) or device behavior (i.e., service object            
          or printer).  We further find that “[a]n object’s behavior                  
          determines such aspects as which views are provided, which user             
          actions are supported, and what should happen in data transfer              
          operations, such as when another object’s icon is dragged to and            
                                          11                                          




Page:  Previous  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  14  15  16  17  18  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007