Ex Parte HAGMANN et al - Page 5




               Appeal No. 2000-0634                                                                                              
               Application No. 08/274,942                                                                                        

               mold cavity has been polymerized, any uncured lens material remaining in the reservoir also                       
               is polymerized for convenience in later handling.  (Col. 7, ll. 49 to 52).  Clark discloses                       
               when the material in the reservoir is allowed to polymerize a flash is formed which should                        
               be removed.  (Col. 8, ll. 47 to 52).                                                                              
                      Appellants argue that Clark does not appreciate the claimed one-step masking process                       
               for forming molded articles and that Clark is directed to a lens mold which is designed to                        
               produce an unfinished contact lens by a sequential two-step process wherein the second step                       
               is the removal of the flash.  (Brief, pp. 3 to 5).  We do not agree.  As stated above, Clark                      
               teaches a process for producing a finished molded lens that does not include a flash as                           
               argued by Appellants.  Appellants are limiting their arguments to the preferred embodiments                       
               of the Clark reference.  A reference is available for all that it teaches, not just the preferred                 
               embodiments.  In re Fritch, 972 F.2d 1260, 1264, 23 USPQ2d 1780, 1782 (Fed. Cir. 1992).                           
               Appellants have chosen to ignore the portions of Clark that disclose polymerizing that                            
               portion of the lens material in the mold which is adjacent to the edge of the mold cavity                         
               should be avoided.  (Col. 7, ll. 5 to 11).  Clark discloses that the polymerization of the lens                   
               material should proceed from the center of the mold outwards in order to avoid and,                               
               consequently, blocking off the reservoir from the center section of the mold cavity.  (Col. 6,                    




                                                               -5-                                                               




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007