Ex Parte WARREN et al - Page 2



          Appeal No. 2000-1042                                                        
          Application No. 08/986,449                                                  
          implanting an antifoulant into the metal object surface via an              
          apparatus such as a cathodic arc plasma gun wherein the apparatus           
          (or the plasma generated thereby) is relatively translated                  
          progressively lengthwise of the surface to uniformly ion implant            
          the surface lengthwise thereof.  This appealed subject matter is            
          adequately illustrated by independent claim 1 which reads as                
          follows:                                                                    
               1. The method for reducing carburization, oxidation, and the           
          formation of coke on a metal object having an elongated surface             
          exposed to hydrocarbon at high temperature in a process, that               
          includes:                                                                   
               a) providing ion implanting apparatus,                                 
               b) operating said apparatus to ion implant selected                    
          antifoulant or antifoulants into the metal object surface,                  
          progressively along said surface,                                           
               c) said metal object configured to have said ion implanted             
          surface exposed to said hydrocarbon at high temperature in said             
          process,                                                                    
               d) said apparatus including a cathodic arc plasma gun which            
          is relatively translated progressively lengthwise of said surface           
          while producing a plasma acting to uniformly ion implant said               
          surface lengthwise thereof.                                                 
               The references set forth below are relied upon by the                  
          examiner as evidence of obviousness:                                        
          Cabrera et al. (Cabrera)           4,714,632      Dec. 22, 1987             
          Conrad                             4,764,394      Aug. 16, 1988             
          Gandman et al. (Gandman)           5,358,626      Oct. 25, 1994             
          Chan (Chan ‘920)                   5,449,920      Sep. 12, 1995             
          Leung                              5,558,718      Sep. 24, 1996             
          Heyse et al. (Heyse)               5,575,902      Nov. 19, 1996             
                                          2                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007