Ex Parte MUNOZ-GARCIA et al - Page 9




          Appeal No. 2001-1185                                                        
          Application No. 08/915,597                                 Page 9           

          unit to a different SO, the end path previously established is              
          changed; (c)each SO is connected to the PSTN 22; (d) no SO                  
          services an area that extends over a boundary 40; (e) future                
          communications are directed through the temporarily assigned SO             
          rather than between the home SIM and the subscriber unit 24, and            
          (f) the serving SO updates its records to include the subscriber            
          unit location and any other data relevant to the service of the             
          subscriber unit through the SO.                                             
               From these teachings of Sowles, we find that when an                   
          alternative SO is temporarily assigned in response to a call                
          to/from an a location outside of the subscriber units' home SIM             
          area, that the temporarily assigned SO (temporarily assigned by             
          the home SIM (col. 10, lines 7-14)) passes messages to and from             
          the alternative gateway or earth station, but that the home SIM             
          does not pass messages to and from the alternative earth station            
          while acting as the gateway into the terrestrial communication              
          system, as required by claim 1.  Based upon our findings, supra,            
          that Sowles does not dislose the home SIM pases messages to/from            
          the alternative earth station while scting as gateway to the                
          terrrestrial commumication system, we consider the examiner's               
          conclusion to the contrary to be speculation, unsupported by                










Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007