Ex Parte VALENTINE - Page 20




         Appeal No. 2002-0652                                                        
         Application No. 08/465,072                                                  


         the discussion on pages 102-105 of undersampling in conjunction             
         with compression is in the section of the specification entitled            
         "Geometric Processor."  Thus, the undersampling circuit would               
         appear to be within the geometric module, as asserted by                    
         appellant.                                                                  
              Appellant points to spatial module 110E in Figure 1A for the           
         spatial interpolation circuit and step of generating spatially              
         interpolated information.  Spatial module 110E follows the                  
         geometric module, and thus would appear to function "in response            
         to" the undersampling circuit which is within the geometric                 
         module.  However, many of the portions of the specification                 
         referenced by appellant for a discussion of interpolation are               
         under the heading of "Geometric Processor."  Thus, it is unclear            
         if the spatial interpolation circuit is "coupled to the                     
         undersampling circuit" and functions "in response to the                    
         undersampled image information" and whether the spatial                     
         interpolation step is "in response to the undersampled image                
         information."                                                               
              Last, for temporal interpolation, appellant directs us, for            
         example, to both element 110A and also element 110R in Figure 1A.           
         None of the drawings explicitly show a temporal interpolation               
         circuit.  Although line 110H in Figure 1A could be considered to            
         take the image information generated by the spacial module for              

                                         20                                          





Page:  Previous  13  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007