Ex Parte VALENTINE - Page 21




         Appeal No. 2002-0652                                                        
         Application No. 08/465,072                                                  


         further processing by the geometric module 110A, it is unclear              
         how element 110R would act "in response to" the image information           
         output by the spacial module.  Furthermore, none of the blocks              
         110 in Figure 110A, for example, is described in the disclosure             
         as capable of performing interpolation.  The disclosure does                
         define temporal interpolation as generating initial conditions              
         for each field (see page 248 and 258), distinguishes between                
         temporal and spatial interpolation (see page 248), and describes            
         an interpolation routine (see pages 269-278 and 281-282), but               
         does not support a temporal interpolation circuit functioning in            
         response to spatially interpolated image information or a                   
         temporal interpolation step in response to spatially interpolated           
         image information.  Accordingly, we agree with the examiner that            
         the disclosure lacks written description support for claims 105             
         and 190.                                                                    
              Claim 191 adds a step to the end of the process of claim               
         191.  As we found no written description support for claim 190,             
         we likewise find no such support for claim 191.  Similarly, claim           
         177 is similar to claim 190 except that it includes further steps           
         between the step of storing input image information and the step            







                                         21                                          




Page:  Previous  14  15  16  17  18  19  20  21  22  23  24  25  26  27  28  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007