Ex Parte BYUN - Page 5




          Appeal No. 2002-1280                                                        
          Application 08/995,996                                                      

          transmitter, the receiver had to be sent to the manufacturer                
          (col. 2, lines 19-23).  The invention in Drori allows the                   
          receiver to be electronically programmed by the user without                
          opening the transmitter and without coding the transmitter or               
          changing or encoding the receiver (col. 2, lines 34-41).                    
               Drori states (col. 7, lines 52-58):                                    
               The transmitter 10 generally comprises the encoder 16 which            
               may be suitably encoded by the manufacturer so that the user           
               is not required to encode the same.  For this purpose, small           
               switches may be provided on the encoder, or other means                
               known in the art could be provided on the encoder for                  
               specifically generating an encoded signal.                             
          One of ordinary skill in the art, reading this passage in                   
          conjunction with the background of the invention, would                     
          appreciate that this refers to the security code or "signature"             
          code and that although, for simplicity, the user is not required            
          to encode the transmitter, the user is not precluded from                   
          defining the code.  The passage indicates that any means known in           
          the art could be used to encode the transmitter, where we find              
          that the "signature" code, when set by a user, corresponds to the           
          claimed "user defined code" set during a "user defined code                 
          setting mode."  Drori teaches that when the user desires to match           
          a transmitter 10 to a receiver 14, the receiver is placed in the            
          program mode (col. 17, lines 8-17), which we find corresponds to            
          the claimed "user defined code setting mode."  The receiver                 
          stores the "signature code" from the transmitter, which                     

                                        - 5 -                                         





Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  9  10  11  12  13  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007