Ex Parte SUMMERS et al - Page 5



          Appeal No. 2003-0599                                                        
          Application 09/362,149                                                      

          single web of material (e.g., metal) and includes a proximal end            
          (14) having attachment structure (16) including a hole (36) in              
          which the actuator spindle (18) is received in fixed relation               
          (specification, page 7).                                                    
          Appellants’ specification indicates, on several occasions,                  
          that an objective of the invention is to provide a novel disk               
          drive suspension of simplified assembly including an actuator               
          arm-free mountable load beam that attaches directly to the                  
          actuator spindle at its proximal end, supports a flexure formed             
          of a flexible conductive laminate adjacent its distal end, and              
          provides a flexure limiter and lift cam integrated with the load            
          beam at its distal end.  By contrast, and contrary to the                   
          examiner’s determination (answer, page 6), the actuator arm (26)            
          of McIlvanie is a two-piece structure having an arm portion (40)            
          and a suspension member (44) attached to the arm portion (40) via           
          spot welds (45).  See particularly, column 2, lines 51-58, of               
          McIlvanie.  Like appellants, we view the arm portion (40) of                
          McIlvanie as being an actuator arm analogous to the actuator arm            
          (34) of Simmons connected to the rotary actuator and the                    
          suspension member (44) as being the “load beam” associated with             
          the slider or read/write head of the disk drive and providing a             

                                          5                                           




Page:  Previous  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  8  Next 

Last modified: November 3, 2007